Berlin ‘very sceptical’ about UniCredit transfer on Commerzbank

Unlock the Editor’s Digest without cost

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.

Opposition throughout the German authorities to a possible takeover of Commerzbank by UniCredit is solidifying, amid anger on the means the Italian financial institution acquired its 9 per cent stake and concern over potential macroeconomic dangers a merger would possibly pose to the German economic system.

Some senior figures in authorities had been “very sceptical” about such a takeover, in line with an individual briefed on inside discussions, partly due to what Berlin considered because the “stealthy means” UniCredit gathered the stake. 

One other individual with direct data of the matter stated UniCredit’s “assault” on Commerzbank was perceived in Berlin as an “unfriendly act.” The individual added it was “nonsensical” for UniCredit’s chief govt Andrea Orcel to argue the German authorities welcomed his bid.

They each spoke beneath the situation of anonymity as a result of the federal government of Chancellor Olaf Scholz has but to kind an official place on a possible merger.

A spokeswoman for the German finance ministry stated the federal government was “analysing the state of affairs”, declining to remark additional.

UniCredit turned Commerzbank’s second-largest shareholder final week after disclosing a 9 per cent stake within the lender, half of which it bought in a single block from the German authorities.

The Monetary Occasions has beforehand reported that the transfer blindsided senior officers in Berlin who had not anticipated a strategic bidder in an public sale geared toward monetary buyers, and had failed to understand till late within the course of that UniCredit had already constructed a 4.5 per cent holding.

The damaging response throughout the authorities suggests UniCredit’s strategy could have backfired, reducing Orcel’s odds of implementing a full takeover.

UniCredit stated: “The [German] authorities ran a completely clear public sale course of for the sale of its stake . . . wherein we had been invited to take part.” Orcel instructed German newspaper Handelsblatt earlier this week that “we’d not have acted had we not been welcome”.

The Commerzbank group tasked with participating with Orcel was additionally involved that UniCredit is likely to be “overexposed to Italy”, 4 folks briefed on inside discussions instructed the FT.

If UniCredit purchases Commerzbank, Berlin could discover itself within the place of getting to bail out the Italian-based lender in case of a monetary disaster, key folks concerned in discussions in Berlin and Frankfurt have argued.

Commerzbank is among the most essential lenders to Germany’s export business and Mittelstand — the small and medium-sized firms that kind the spine of the nation’s economic system. 

The German lender is led by former Bundesbank president Jens Weidmann, who in his earlier job repeatedly warned about excessive ranges of sovereign debt in Eurozone international locations.

Italy’s public debt ratio is the second-highest within the Euro space, and greater than double that of Germany’s. Moody’s charges German sovereign debt at AAA, the best potential ranking, whereas Italy’s, at Baa3, is only one notch above junk.

Officers in Berlin are additionally involved {that a} merger, which unions worry would result in 1000’s of job losses at Commerzbank and UniCredit’s Munich-based German subsidiary HypoVereinsbank, might develop into a difficulty for subsequent yr’s election marketing campaign, on the expense of Scholz’s unpopular coalition.

Nevertheless the German authorities, which has but to formulate a unified place on UniCredit’s curiosity in Commerzbank, is conscious it must tread rigorously as Germany has been a supporter of European integration and a capital markets union, the folks stated.

Germany’s highly effective companies sector union, Verdi, has vowed to battle any deal between the 2 banks “tooth and nail”, whereas opposition politicians from the centre-right CDU and the leftwing BSW have additionally voiced considerations.

Alexander Lorz, a CDU politician and finance minister of the German state of Hesse, instructed the FT that the state anticipated the federal authorities to strengthen Frankfurt’s standing as a monetary centre. “We’re centered on the pursuits of Germany’s most essential monetary hub,” he stated.

The Italian authorities is supportive of a Commerzbank takeover — offered that the headquarters of an enlarged pan-European lender stays in Italy, in line with folks acquainted with Rome’s pondering. UniCredit wants approval from the ECB to boost its stake above 9.9 per cent. Reuters first reported the Italian authorities stance.

UniCredit stated it had been a “robust supporter of the German economic system for nearly 20 years” by means of HypoVereinsbank, acquired in a uncommon cross-border deal in 2005.

“We stay satisfied that Commerzbank has considerably higher potential to ship — and if we might help them to do this — both as a shareholder or a associate — we’re prepared to take action.”  

Commerzbank declined to remark.

Further reporting by Silvia Sciorilli Borrelli in Milan.